Why I think male circumcision is a big issue

Richard Duncker is one of the UK’s leading campaigners against medically unnecessary male circumcision. Here he explains why circumcision is such a big issue.

—This is article #19 in our series of #100Voices4Men and boys

There are about three billion men alive in the world today. Approximately two billion of them are allowed to grow up with their genitals intact. The remaining one billion have their genitals cut; they are circumcised without their consent, usually when they are children.

Physical harm and loss of sensation

The removal of about 90 square centimetres of specialised erogenous tissue is clearly physical harm. The anatomy of the penis and the foreskin in particular has been studied by Cold and Taylor [1] and a fair summary is that fine touch nerves and stretch receptors are removed during a circumcision. These are the types of nerves that let you locate a splinter in your finger and create good feelings when you smile. At the junction of the inner and outer foreskin is an extension of the frenulum (banjo string) that is the ridged band of nerves that runs around the opening of the foreskin.

In their 2007 study Sorrells et al [2] identified the ridged band as the most sensitive area of the penis. This area is always lost to circumcision. There is also the fact that nerves that are cut do not join up as they heal and the brain will map the sensation from the affected area unpredictably. It is probably fair to say that a man without a foreskin experiences sex in a similar manner to a person trying to speak after the dentist has numbed their lip [3].

Such a loss compromises the sex life of the man concerned. Frisch et al in their study [4] conclude that “Circumcision was associated with frequent orgasm difficulties in Danish men and with a range of frequent sexual difficulties in women” They also go on to say that a “Thorough examination of these matters in areas where male circumcision is more common is warranted.” So far no one has been willing to fund such a study.

Hospitals regularly care for boys who have suffered complications as a result of circumcision, FOI (freedom of information) requests are pending. It seems from previous FOI requests that an almost equal proportion of casualties resulting from circumcision come from medical and lay operators. Some of these injuries are life threatening as this report of complications in one Birmingham hospital shows [7].

Deaths

That boys have died as a result of genital cutting is now widely known, news stories from London, Manchester, Africa and hospitals in America show that deaths are not rare and represent the most extreme form of physical harm.

Psychological harm

After circumcision there are a number of possible psychological outcomes. Some men, an unknown proportion of those circumcised, will go on to live happy lives oblivious to any adverse effects their circumcision may have had on them. Lindsay Watson in his excellent book “Unspeakable Mutilations” [5] describes this state as the “circumcision coma” and that such men are in denial or are genuinely happy with their status but no one knows the proportions, it seems that no one wants to know or study the answer.

Some of the men circumcised will have a negative reaction to their circumcision and may be described as suffering from Post Circumcision Syndrome referred to by Dr John Warren in his video interview with James Loewen.

There has been work done on the psychological damage caused by circumcision and a good place to start is – Circumcision and Resources Information Page – where you will find links into a lot of work on this subject. There is a spectrum of psychological, economic and social damage that remains to be studied. Some men report depression, inability to form relationships and shame about their bodies.

I have been told, by impeccable sources, of at least two suicides where a note showed that circumcision was a significant contributory factor for the suicide.

So to conclude – of about a billion men that is 1,000,000,000, some live possibly in ignorance and unaffected by the damage they have been caused. A proportion of that billion live only too aware and resentful of what has been done to them and others may feel damaged but unable to identify or admit the cause. The numbers of men in each category are unknown and the dead are uncounted. What is certain is that male circumcision is a big problem. Even if only a small fraction of that billion are damaged it is still a large amount of suffering. It is surely time that non-therapeutic male circumcision followed the path identified by the sociologist C Wright Mills and moved from being a private trouble to becoming a public issue.

FOOTNOTES:

[1] “The prepuce: specialized mucosa of the penis and its loss to circumcision” J .R. Taylor, A.P . Lockwood and A. J. Taylor Department of Pathology, Health Sciences Centre, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada

[2] “Fine-touch pressure thresholds in the adult penis” Morris L. Sorrells, James L. Snyder, Mark D. Reiss, Christopher Eden*, Marilyn F. Milos†,Norma Wilcox and Robert S. Van Howe

[3] Lower lip key to smile and kisses

[4] “Male circumcision and sexual function in men and women: a survey-based, cross-sectional study in Denmark” International Journal of Epidemiology 2011

[5] “Unspeakable Mutilations Circumcised Men Speak Out” Lindsay R Watson

[6] C. Wright Mills: power, craftsmanship, and private troubles and public issues

[7] Botched circumcision put 100 boys in A&E in Birmingham

—Picture credit: Men Do Complain website

To find out more about Richard Duncker’s Men Do Complain campaign you visit their website or follow them on facebook or twitter.

You can find all of the #100Voices4Men articles that will be published in the run up to International Men’s Day 2014 by clicking on this link—#100Voices4Men—and follow the discussion on twitter by searching for #100Voices4Men.

The views expressed in these articles are not the views of insideMAN editorial team. Whether you agree with the views expressed in this article or not we invite you to take take part in this important discussion, our only request is that you express yourself in a way that ensures everyone’s voice can be heard.

You can join the #100Voices4Men discussion by commenting below; by following us on Twitter @insideMANmag and Facebook or by emailing insideMANeditor@gmail.com.

Patrick Smyth

Thanks for this impressively comprehensive exposition Richard. I reflect that when I was a child I read tales of fantasy and of scary monsters and unbelievable happenings. It seems that the real world is as much a fantasy world as many I read about as a child. In the real world many parents see to it that their own children are brutally assaulted and robbed of their birthright to live their life with the whole body they were born with. In the real world it is however considered repugnant by any civilised person to inflict such an abomination on a female, but they are quite content that to do such a thing to a male is not harmful and even beneficial. Thus we have millions of men who were circumcised without any choice in the matter are indoctrinated into believing that they are normal and are enjoying the wholesome sexual experience that other men with a whole body enjoy. Fact is indeed stranger than fiction it would seem. Thanks Glen and Dan for your support.
http://www.CircumcisionHarm.org Tim Hammond

While the medical community has failed to examine the long-term adverse outcomes of infant circumcision on boys and the men they become, a grassroots effort was twice undertaken by affected men. The first was published in 1999 and can be found here: http://www.noharmm.org/images/Preliminary%20Poll%201999.pdf

The second survey was done online as the Global Survey of Circumcision Harm: http://www.CircumcisionHarm.org More than 1,000 men, 4% of whom were Jewish, responded by documenting the physical, sexual, emotional, self-esteem and psychological damage they continue to live with decades after their genitals were cut as unconsenting children.

Usually there are no resources for affected men to turn to for help. Here in Vancouver, Canada there’s an effort to reach out to these men in a series of meetings entitled “Healing the Wounds of Circumcision”. There’s clearly a need for this type of support but inviting men to trust others is a huge obstacle to getting such support groups off the ground. There’s always a first time! http://checkhimout.ca/healing-wounds/
Nigel

I have to admit to being quite ignorant of this issue until quite recently. It is quite clear that this surgery is done without the person’s consent and there are no pressing best interest factors making it medically imperative to do such at a very young age. Consequently , as with any other medical procedure it should be left to the young man to decide on ( for cultural or other reasons) when considered old enough to decide on such an issue. It is odd that a potentially risky and only very rarely medically necessary surgery is so casually dealt with.
http://www.intactamerica.org/ Greg Hartley

Thanks, Richard, for this clear, concise and persuasive article. All children, regardless of gender, culture or parental religion, have a fundamental right to all their healthy, functional body parts. My body belongs to me!
Lawrence Newman

Circumcision is sexual crippling. All the erogenous nerves are in the parts cut off. It’s utter barbarism.
- yachty
  
  Again, just BS from you! You and all your anti ILK just lie about everything!
  - Lawrence Newman
    
    Another mad sexual crippling promoting the abuse he suffered himself.
    - yachty
      
      Dude, stay in the Uk with all your Muslims! Brits are all full of shit! I was never abused, only perfected! Uncircumcised males are below my dogs! Seriously they are a lower life form!
      - Lawrence Newman
        
        You hate muslims and yet you support their most degenerate practice. You’re a confused simpleton.
      - yachty
        
        No, I am a Jew! Muslims are BS! They don’t even circumcise until the boy is 10-14 with out any numbing agents! They are animals! Jews give the world health and innovation…..
      - Lawrence Newman
        
        “I am a Jew” And all becomes clear.
      - yachty
        
        What does that mean? My father isn’t Jewish, but you can bet he is circumcised! My brother became a (dare I say) a Christian (converted for his bitch wife), but his son’s are circumcised. Seriously I never knew any guy that wasn’t cut…..all our friends have circumcised their boys as well. You are just some FU European with a nasty foreskin!
      - Lawrence Newman
        
        It means you’re brainwashed.
      - yachty
        
        You are a dumb ass!
- yachty
  
  You are a mental cripple! Your problem is between your ears, not between your legs!

Share article